Today, I spotlight the bizarrely cheap credits change made by The Hogan Family from Season 4 to Season 5.
Knowledge Waits is a feature where I just share some bit of pop culture history that interests me that doesn’t quite fit into the other features.
It is a well-accepted fact that credits for TV shows are oddly expensive. Basically, it’s like shooting a commercial, but you’re not being paid to shoot the commercial, it’s simply taken out of the general budget of the TV show. Even something as simple as adding or replacing a character from a credit sequence can be so cost prohibitive that Joss Whedon wasn’t allowed to have Eric Balfour (whose character dies in the first episode) be part of the cast credits in the first episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, as the gag cost too much (years later, Whedon was allowed to do it with Amber Benson’s Tara, who was added to the credits in the episode she was killed).
However, I think the cheapest example of a credits change has to be The Hogan Family, the family sitcom that went through a few different names after its original star, Valerie Harper, was fired following a contract dispute, and thus Valerie became Valerie’s Family became The Hogans became The Hogan Family.
Season 4 and Season 5 had pretty much the same casts, except for one of David Hogan (Jason Bateman)’s friends, played by Tom Hodges, was let go between seasons.
In Season 4, Steve Witting (Burt) and Hodges (Rich) shared a scene in the credits. First Witting…
then Hodges…
For Season 5, with Hodges now OFF of the show, the scene remained, but only Witting is credited!
That’s NUTS. Just spring for an extra scene, for crying out loud!
Drop me a line at brian@popculturereferences.com if you have any other interesting bit about pop culture that you’d like me to discuss!
C’mon, Brian, if they sprang for added credits scenes, that means one less Corvette for the producers.
All jokes aside, I didn’t know that intro credits for TV shows were so oddly expensive. No wonder plenty of shows just run clips from the pilot (or from episodes during the season) with text crawling over it rather than film any new footage. That way even when you change things to account for new characters (like, say, the various intros for TJ HOOKER did), it’s cheaper because they’re essentially using stock footage.
With The Hogans, couldn’t they have done something to “zoom in” on Bateman and Witting, which would essentially cut Hodges out of frame? I mean, we had pan-and-scan for movies on broadcast television.
Remember when Turner debuted widescreen format and people needed to be sold on it? I remember seeing ads for 2001 comparing letterbox to standard showing how two characters could be in a shot instead of cutting between them.
I think it’s less that it is particularly expensive and more that it is just ENOUGH of an added expense that they prefer just to avoid as much of the costs as possible, as the costs would have to come out of the much more important regular episode budgets. Choosing between making a cooler looking opening credits and giving a better ending to Episode, like, 17, I think most TV producers would go with the latter.
The last name of Sandy Duncan’s father had the last name Hogan but wasn’t Hogan the last name of Sandy Duncan’s husband? Why did they allow this blooper?
I assume Sandy just went back to her maiden name when she got divorced.
do we even know she took her busband’s last name to begin with.
Nope. It’s possible she kept her maiden name.
Guesses as to expense:
* Trailers are a specific type of editing, done by different people to the editing of films (except for Suicide Squad). Opening titles seem like they’re the same. Specialist editors, possibly not even in-house. So rather than being part of the process of making an episode, they’re an additional task.
* They’re a once-off job, but they appear up to 26 times a year and perhaps multiple years. They’re probably charged at many times their “value” to cover that. Although Joss was looking at an one-time use for Buffy, perhaps negotiating a reduced price was “too hard.”
* While adding a single credit for an episode seems easy, opening titles are synced to the theme song, so it’s probably a lot more work than just adding a clip. Plus, you’d probably need a different group shot, etc.
And, the reality is it wouldn’t have been much of a problem. Watching a first episode, especially where the cast isn’t famous, you usually don’t notice who is or isn’t in the credits first time through. Later viewings, maybe, but then you already know the twist.
Ads for shows and the information released and speculation before them are bigger issues. Not as much of a probably back then, but certainly now. Torchwood promoted their show pretending that the first episode death was an ongoing character (but they also included her in the first episode’s credits)